Categories
Epistemology Theology

Foundationalism and theTrinity

My post about Nancy Pearcy’s book Total Truth led to some good discussion about the limits of logic. In particular, there was some discussion about whether the doctrine of the Trinity is “logical.” To me, the doctrine of the Trinity is a severe test for any kind of foundationalism in which human reason and perception are considered basic.

It seems to me that the doctrine of the Trinity fails the test of human logic, and therefore should not be considered a legitimate belief by a foundationalist. Of course, as a Christian, I, along with most if not all of my foundationalist Evangelical friends, do believe in the doctrine of the Trinity. So what I’d like to do is explore a bit of my thinking on this, and invite my friends in the blogsphere who’ve been defending at least a “modest” foundationalism to explain how their criteria for truth square with believing the doctrine of the Trinity. (As usual, I don’t claim to know it all here, and I’m in the process of exploring these thoughts myself.)

Categories
Uncategorized

A Sign that You are Watching too Much HGTV

My wife loves Home and Garden “fix-it” TV. Tonight I was discussing with my 7 year old son the sorts of things he wanted to pray for. He mentioned toys, money, and that “we won’t have any sewage problems.” A recent HGTV show apparently featured a family with a broken sewage line, and the footage of raw sewage in their backyard made a big impression on my boy. Sheesh.

Categories
Uncategorized

New York City Today


Here is my image of NYC today. And a Haiku:

Frozen commuters
starting down the icy street,
hoping for the thaw.

Categories
Uncategorized

Through the Looking Glass — Blog Roundup

Through the Looking Glass today:

Brad Hightower at 21st Century Reformation discusses how 1 Cor. 1:22 suggests true knowledge exists only in the context of relationship with God through Christ.

Stones Cry Out reports on the global decline of atheism.

Tod Bolsinger writes about how regular meals can become sacramental. He asks: “How would our lives be different if we didn’t ‘limit’ the Lord’s Supper to the Holy High Tea that we celebrate once a quarter, once a month, even once a week, but instead was the mystery in every meal, every time?”

Categories
Uncategorized

Today's Lesson from Isaiah

I am God, and there is none like me.
I make known the end from the beginning,
from ancient times, what is still to come.
I say: My purpose will stand,
and I will do all that I please.
From the east I summon a bird of prey;
from a far-off land, a man to fulfill my purpose.
What I have said, that will I bring about;
what I have planned, that will I do.

Isaiah 46:9-11.

We don’t always, or often, understand how or when God will fulfill His purposes. Yet every small detail of His plans is orchestrated as He wills — even down to a single bird or man summoned from far off to accomplish one task. How foolish to think God has forgotten to judge, and how comforting to know God has not forgotten to bless.

Categories
Uncategorized

Through the Looking Glass – Blog Roundup

Through the looking glass today:

Smart Christian announces that the Christian Blogcon is set for October 13-15 at Biola University in California. Looks like a great lineup!

Jollyblogger compares the notion of “cyberchurch” with Gnosticism. Very interesting, and on point, I think.

Aaron at The Voiz discusses how giving technology — specifically video technology — to the powerless can help fight injustice, and references the film Born in Brothels. What a great movement this could become! The Christian Blogcon should include discussion of this sort of thing.

Categories
Uncategorized

Today's View from NYC

Empire State BuildingHere’s the view from my walk to work in NYC yesterday. Anyone who claims to enjoy winter doesn’t work in the city.

Categories
Uncategorized

Through the Looking Glass — Blog Roundup

Through the Looking Glass today:

Alan Creech writes that while Christian books, seminars and weblogs can be useful, “What I don’t think is healthy, though, is not realizing that God has provided for us, by His Holy Spirit, in the Community of the Faith, in our local and regional contexts, all that we really need in order to be fully developed as Human Beings like Jesus.”

Emergent US considers an “Emerging Theologians” series to highlight work by “currently unpublished” authors. Interesting. Are bloggers who read alot but never went to seminary and have published in other fields eligble, I wonder?

Jason Clark writes about how his personal struggles with depression and anxiety led him to the Emergent movement and says “theology saved my faith.” I wonder how many other evangelicals or former evangelicals have been drawn to deep study of theology, and perhaps to the Emergent movement, through wrestling with the black dog of depression. Jason’s story resonated with me in so many ways. Someday, maybe soon, I’ll post about my own fights with panic and the black dog.

Categories
Uncategorized

The View from NJ

Snow in NJHere is the view from New Jersey today. I used to love this stuff. Now I have to shovel it. Oh well, at least I get some fresh air and exercise!

Categories
Uncategorized

The Nature of Truth Metaphors

In response to some of the interesting comments and dialogue recently over the nature of and basis for truth claims, I’m going to make an effort to explain my current thinking about these issues. I should say at the outset that I’m still working through many of these thoughts, so my posts about them are in the nature of conversations about my thought process rather than dogmatic claims.

When we speak of things like “foundationalism” and “truth webs,” we’re employing metaphors to describe the nature of human knowledge. No metaphor, of course, is perfect. Given the limited utility of metaphors, we need to be particularly careful about how closely we identify our thinking with any given metaphor. As Christians, the metaphors we use to understand the nature of knowledge and truth should never divide us. These metaphors are simply tools that help us understand a reality we can’t fully grasp, and they should always be held loosely.

That said, here’s how I understand the metaphors of the foundation and the web, and some reasons why I think the foundation metaphor is problematic and the web metahpor preferable.